Ask Casey: A Bourbon Peach Lemonade for Daytime Drinking

Ask Casey: Cooking and Kitchen Questions Answered
I am heading out to a tailgate party this weekend that involves a horse race, fancy hats, and daytime drinking. Do you have any great ideas for a fun, adults-only beverage I could make ahead to share with the group?

Let’s play a word association game! When I think of horses, I think of Kentucky. And when I think of Kentucky, I think of bourbon. I mean, doesn’t everyone?

So it’s a natural assumption that any drink you’re stirring up for a party that involves adults in fancy hats—scratch that, for any easy breezy outdoor party at all—should involve a big glug of bourbon. As Julie Andrews says, it’s a very good place to start.

bourbon peach lemonade, via
The second place you’ll want to go after you pull the bourbon out of your liquor cabinet is over to the grill, because that bourbon is going to taste even better when you mix it with lemonade. Specifically fresh lemonade. And though it’s not a requirement that the lemons be grilled before you squeeze them, I’m strongly suggesting it because of the incredibly summery, smoky flavor it imparts to the finished drink. (And we all know how much I love smoky grilled fruit in my drinks.)

There’s no trick or mystery to grilling lemons: just cut ’em in half and place ’em face-down on your screaming-hot grill grates for a few minutes. Some people brush the cut side of the lemons with honey or dip them in granulated sugar before grilling. Again, not a requirement—I grill my lemons naked and they char up just fine without any additional sugar.

grilled lemons for lemonade, via
So grill your lemons if you can, but rest easy: I’m not going to force you into grilling a whole tree’s worth of peaches and puréeing them to get 4 cups’ worth of peach juice for this drink. There are enough excellent options for organic peach nectar in the supermarket that we can hedge our bets here. I am, however, going to make you do one last thing to send this lemonade into the stratosphere.

It’s called brown sugar simple syrup, and it really is simple—follow the same 1:1 ratio of sugar to water that you’d use to make regular simple syrup, but switch it up with brown sugar instead of white granulated sugar. It’s almost as good as using maple sugar or maple syrup but a lot less pricey. You can make the same substitution with coconut sugar or demerara sugar, if you’d like. Both the grilled citrus and the brown sugar are deepening the flavor of the lemonade, giving you more of that caramelized sweetness that mimics the charred oak-and-vanilla undertones of the bourbon.

The following recipe makes a whole jug of lemonade, enough to keep the party going for a while. If you plan on keeping the drink over ice in a large pitcher or drink dispenser for a few hours, you can add less water to the finished product so it won’t dilute too much as the ice melts.

bourbon peach lemonade, via
Cheers, tally ho, well done, and move your bloomin’ arse, or whatever they say at horse races! (Sorry, my horse knowledge is limited to the polo match scene from Pretty Woman and My Fair Lady.)

FTC Disclosure: Good. Food. Stories. is an affiliate and receives a minuscule commission on all purchases made through Amazon links in our posts. If you'd like to support the site further, please use this link or click the Amazon links in the sidebar to make your purchases.

Get it While it’s Hot!

Sign up to receive the latest Good. Food. Stories. while they are still piping hot, directly to your inbox.


  1. Carol says

    I couldn’t even wait to read the entire recipe to comment! I had to start my brown sugar simple syrup! I can taste it now! Thank you for this perfectly summery recipe just when I needed a new taste! You had me at grilled lemons!