The Bar Cart: A Pickled Surfer at Ditch Plains

Yeah, I’ll admit it. The oft-stereotyped hipster has been an easy target in these pages throughout the years, and no doubt we at Good. Food. Stories. will continue to nitpick away at the mob mentality and quasi-ridiculous trendmongering (hey, it’s New York; we call it like we see it). But from chaos often comes beauty, and like a sculptor coaxing delicate limbs and faces from rough stone, sometimes an artist can polish a kernel of a good idea into something truly great.

pickled surfer cocktail, ditch plains
Take the pickleback, one of those ideas that—like men wearing chest hair-exposing deep v-neck t-shirts and both genders sporting thick black-rimmed glasses when they’ve got perfect eyesight—seems inexplicably wrong at first glance. A pickleback, for those of you not inclined to frequent the bars of Williamsburg or Ludlow Street, is a shot of whiskey chased with a shot of dill pickle juice. It’s that simple.

And you’d think that someone who’s both a whiskey fanatic and a dill pickle addict would start sucking these things down with abandon, right? No dice. Pickleback fans claim that the sour brine mellows whiskey’s fiery aftertaste, but that’s not what I tasted. Rather than being more than the sum of its parts, I got no pleasure from the Frankensteinian marriage of these two unwilling partners.

Here’s the twist (you knew there was one, right?). My favorite West Village surf shack Ditch Plains (home of the mac and cheese-slathered Ditch Dog) makes their own bread and butter pickles for battering and frying, chopping into housemade tartar sauce, topping an already towering burger, and even eating as a side dish, should you be so brine-inclined.

It’s this brine, the sugar- and turmeric-infused neon juice from the bread and butter slices, that Ditch Plains mixes with whiskey to make a cocktail called The Pickled Surfer. (It’s an urban fish shack, get it?) Citrus comes to the rescue once again, with a squeeze of lime juice that cuts both the sweetness and the burn for a truly mellow finish to each sip. Think whiskey sour, but brighter and less cloying. Think margarita, but deeper and more savory.

The Pickled Surfer plays well with fried oysters and clams on a sunny, last-gasp-of-summer day, or with a plate of chicken chili nachos when the first hint of fall is in the air and the first weeks of football hit the airwaves. And it’s sippable instead of shootable, making this an oldster’s drink for those of us who prefer a slower pace. That’s a trend I can get behind.

Ditch Plains uses Bushmills in their version of the drink, but everyone’s got a favorite; I’ve been making mine with a bottom-shelf Canadian blend from the back of the liquor cabinet. Bourbon, with its vanilla undertones, might enhance the Surfer’s sweetness further. Give it a try with your most beloved malt and let me know the results.

FTC Disclosure: Good. Food. Stories. is an affiliate and receives a minuscule commission on all purchases made through Amazon links in our posts. If you'd like to support the site further, please use this link or click the Amazon links in the sidebar to make your purchases.

Get it While it’s Hot!

Sign up to receive the latest Good. Food. Stories. while they are still piping hot, directly to your inbox.


  1. Joan says

    Ok, I could give this a try…. Happen to have a friend’s delicious homemade bread-and-butter pickles in the fridge right now, although I wouldn’t mind trying the original at Ditch Plains..whenever I get there!!

  2. Dick Witt says

    Where did you get the photo? I would like to get a license to use it on a menu I’m creating.

    • Casey BarberCasey Barber says

      Dick, all site images unless specifically noted are original copyrighted property of Good. Food. Stories. I’d be happy to speak with you further about a price quote for licensing any of my photography, however. Please check your email for more details!