Salty-Sweet Summer Treat: Peanut Butter Caramel Drumstick Cones

As hard-to-find nostalgic treats go, I’m not sure the vanilla caramel Drumstick tops too many people’s lists. After all, the regular vanilla version is all over the place, there are chocolate ice cream versions, fudge-core options, and even varieties with Nestle Crunch in place of the usual dome of peanuts—enough to make the casual ice cream eater gorge for weeks.

homemade peanut butter caramel drumstick cones, via
But for me, it’s caramel or nothing. I don’t want a Drumstick without that crucial gooey core. And for whatever reason, it’s been an elusive find around New Jersey for the past few years. It doesn’t appear in any of Nestle’s variety packs, so those were useless to me. I’d see a box in one grocery store and gleefully snag it, only to come up short the next time I stopped in.

I got Dan in on the hunt: Target became a semi-regular source for my stash, so we took to stalking the frozen treats aisle there and hoarding boxes three at a time when we’d spot the signature orange wave on the package.

A few times, we’d half-joke about just throwing up our hands and making them from scratch, but a homemade ice cream Drumstick never made it off the planning boards—even during recipe testing for Classic Snacks Made from Scratch, which now strikes me as a criminal oversight. After all, it’s made of a bunch of ingredients I already make from scratch: ice cream, caramel, and chocolate magic shell. (Not doing homemade cones yet, but give me time.)

homemade peanut butter caramel drumstick cones, via
What finally pushed me over the edge and into action was a brainstorm for a simple but irresistible customization: peanut butter caramel, a rich and salty tweak to my favorite basic caramel sauce. Someone with a salt tooth as strong as mine can’t resist the pull of peanut butter and caramel together—it’s a pairing that might even beat the pants off peanut butter and chocolate if it came down to it in a deathmatch. (A delicious, fictional deathmatch.)

Thus inspired, I decided to go one further with my custom Drumsticks and coated the interior of my cones with salted caramelized white chocolate instead of regular chocolate magic shell. The result of the tweaking is a homemade ice cream treat with just enough of an edge, hitting all the nostalgic notes of the original caramel-filled cone, but with a sassy underpinning.

filling homemade drumstick cones, via
Dare I make the next round with peanut-studded salted caramel ice cream next time? Dare I add crushed pretzels to the topping? Or is that just gilding the lily?

(Oh, and if you were ever looking to make a uni-tasker into a multitasker, a jalapeño grill rack makes a perfect holder for keeping cones upright as they chill. I knew there was a reason to keep that thing around!)

FTC Disclosure: Good. Food. Stories. is an affiliate and receives a minuscule commission on all purchases made through Amazon links in our posts. If you'd like to support the site further, please use this link or click the Amazon links in the sidebar to make your purchases.

Get it While it’s Hot!

Sign up to receive the latest Good. Food. Stories. while they are still piping hot, directly to your inbox.


  1. says

    I was already pretty convinced just by the title . . . but then I saw the pouring photos of the peanut butter caramel and that sealed the deal. I MUST make and eat too many of these.

    • CaseyCasey says

      Confession: I maaaay have drizzled extra peanut butter caramel OVER the peanuts and chocolate on my Drumstick before eating it. Too much is never enough! Also, if your salt tooth is as strong as mine, I HIGHLY recommend using the caramelized white chocolate with a pinch of Maldon on/in your cones. It adds a little extra hit of sweet-salty that makes me want to eat the entire dozen in one sitting.