Ask Casey: What’s the Deal with Wineglasses?

Casey Barber

by Casey Barber on April 15, 2011

Ask Casey: Cooking and Kitchen Questions Answered

Does it really matter if you serve red wine in one kind of wineglass and white wine in another—do all the different shapes and sizes of stemware really make a difference?

Hey, don’t blame Riedel and other schmancy stemware manufacturers for overloading our brains and wallets with different glasses for Syrah, Chardonnay, Burgundy, and Cabernet. Blame stupid nature for making so many different varieties of wine grapes!

It’s kind of a ridiculous marketing ploy, but as any oenophile will tell you, wine is a living, breathing, constantly changing organism, and—no offense to the design minds at Schiller’s Liquor Bar, who serve their carafes of vino with the cutest little bistro glasses—things taste a little differently in a small stubby glass than in a bell-shaped, tapered goblet in which you can slosh and sniff to your heart’s content.

wine glass, stemware

“The shape absolutely has an impact,” says Mandy Oser, who runs the casually elegant Hell’s Kitchen food and wine bar Ardesia. “It’s not necessarily about cost or a particular brand, it’s more about the thickness of the glass, the weight of it.”

Aldo Sohm, Chef Sommelier at Le Bernardin, elaborates: “A well-made glass can act as a magnifying glass for flavor and aroma.” He focuses on the rim of the glass as a barometer of quality: a thin, precise and angled edge is what he’s looking for.

Though the idea that different regions of the tongue pick up different flavors—sweet, salty, sour, bitter—has been debunked, Sohm provides a compelling reason to drink out of delicately formed stemware instead of juice glasses. The narrow openings and wide bowls of red and white wine glasses allow the all-important nose or bouquet (wine aromas) to make its olfactory impact before you sip, while letting the wine “breathe” and develop flavors after being released from its bottle.

Champagne and sparkling wines, on the other hand, benefit from V-shaped bowls that promote the constant rise of carbonation from the narrow bottom to the slightly wider top, tickling your nose and tastebuds with that festive fizz.

Oser suggests doing a little taste test with a few wineglasses that you’re considering investing in—Ardesia uses the Spiegelau brand at its bar, which are also the Barber house wineglasses as well. Take a trip to your local wine bar and talk to your neighborhood sommelier. Or you can invest in a few of the Universal glasses that Sohm designed for Zalto, intended to be used for both red and white wines.

Beyond the scientific taste tests, the bottom line is this: investing in a good set of wineglasses—whether from Riedel, Zalto, Ikea, or Crate & Barrel—will help you get the most out of the wine you’re drinking. Don’t break the bank if you know you’re the kind of person who’s going to be breaking the stems on a regular basis, but it all leads to the enjoyment of a good glass or two, and isn’t that the point? To eat and drink things that taste the best they possibly can?

But beware the pleasures of taste-testing wines in various pieces of stemware: eventually, you might become the person who sends incorrect stemware back to the kitchen, or worse yet, brings your own with you. (Um, not that I know anyone in my personal life who does those two things. No, never.)

Whether you’re flummoxed by the finer points of serving fromage or just need a quick primer on preparing prime rib, Ask Casey is here to help. Got a question? Email me and I’ll answer it here.

FTC Disclosure: Good. Food. Stories. is an Amazon.com affiliate and receives a minuscule commission on all purchases made through Amazon links in our posts. If you'd like to support the site further, please use this link or click the Amazon links in the sidebar to make your purchases.

{ 10 comments… read them below or add one }

Justin April 15, 2011 at 10:54 am

We have a fleet of different wine glasses at our place . . . Riedel & Spiegaleu varietal specific glasses, free Winery-logo glasses from tastings, fancy non-specific glasses that we got for our wedding . . . and you do see a difference side-by-side!

For big dinner parties and tasting great bottles we’ll break out the Riedels. However, for every day simplicity we’ll use the cheap winery glasses, mostly because we can throw them in the dishwasher and if we occasionally break a stem then no big deal.

We’re finding a nice compromise are the Riedel O glasses that have no stem (dishwasher friendly, but maybe hard swallow for purists) and have a thin rim and built are for varietal quaffing. I only have two, but am eying a set of 6 on Amazon . . .

Cheers!

justin

Reply

Gburg April 15, 2011 at 11:36 am

Okay, I admit I am the one “who sends incorrect stemware back to the kitchen, or worse yet, brings your own with you”, but if you are drinking great wines, you should demand the proper stemware. For those of you that drink Boones Farm, don’t worry about it.
Great article and so true.

Reply

C.C. April 15, 2011 at 12:52 pm

C.C. may have no idea how to load a dishwasher and prefers to leave that task to the experts, but she does find great enjoyment in following the rules for wineglasses: reds in wider, large bowl glasses, whites in narrower glasses and don’t hold by the bowl–B.F. that mean you!)–and universal glasses that are stemless are wonderfully soothing because even after the third glass, your chances of breakage still remain quite low. ;-)

Reply

sarah henry April 15, 2011 at 3:57 pm

Sometimes, if you’re in a certain mood, a recycled jam jar does the job.

Reply

wino April 15, 2011 at 5:30 pm

I found a kitchen wholesale store in Quebec City, Quebec that sells Reidel’s for $99.00/dozen. You have to buy all of the same kind, but at $8.25 per glass for Reidel’s, that is a great buy and they are our everyday wine glasses.

Reply

Melanie Haiken April 16, 2011 at 1:19 am

Gosh, I beg to disagree, but I finally followed the Italians and use sturdy wide-mouthed water glasses and they work great. I got tired of broken glasses and stemware that didn’t fit in the dishwasther!

Reply

b & b hotels india April 16, 2011 at 2:38 am

I finally followed the Italians and use sturdy wide-mouthed water glasses and they work great.

Reply

wino April 16, 2011 at 11:11 am

Not all Italians drink out of those water-glasses. I spent 12 days in Italy last summer and most of the good restaurants used good stemware [including Reidel], especially in Piemonte, Rome, and the Lake Region

Reply

Lisa (dinner party) April 20, 2011 at 12:26 pm

Not only do I use incorrect glasses for wine, I admit to slipping an ice cube or two in my whites! [shame]

Reply

Wine Glass May 21, 2013 at 3:28 pm

Justin, how do you travel with your Riedel glasses so they don’t break?

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: